INDIAN
INSTITUTE FOR RESEARCH INTO TRUE HISTORY
Newsletter
No 28 of
1 News and current affairs
1.1 Change of telephone
numbers
Mr Godbole can now be contacted on 01234 357388 (home) and
0171 200 2512 (office)
1.2
Taj Mahal and the Great British Conspiracy
* All the work is now on a computer disc. A copy of the disc was sent to
Viarj
Sardesai for spread on Electronic Mail in
* Four friends have promised a total of Rs 20,000 for publication, If
you too want to help, it will be welcome. Publication will start as soon as
possible.
1.3
Why Rewrite Indian History ?
Copies of this booklet are available from Mr Godbole.
1.4 The Falsity of
Indo-Saracenic Architecture
Mr Godbole has typed all his notes. They need extensive editing. He needs
a list of Hindu structures : temples, forts, palaces etc where semicircular or pointed
arches, and domes are employed. Please write to him if you have details of such
examples.
1.5 Taj Mahal: Facts and
Fantasies
One slide show was arranged on 31 July at
camp, attended. Of these 150 were youngsters and 30 were elderly
officials.
It was a hot sticky evening, but the show went well. As a result of this
show
Mr Godbole met RSS officers from
(Ahmedabad ), and
1.6 Around
Two such tours took place
• First one was on 18 June. Eight RSS workers of
• Second tour was on 12 August. Twelve people attended, five were
visitors from
• Mr Malhar Kulkarni, a Ph D student of
• Visitors from
If you can help in furthering this cause please contact Mr Godbole.
A query has been made for such a tour by Mr Pandav of
• A video of the tour has been made. Modifications have also been made
by Mr Padhya. It is expected that another attempt will be made in January 1996.
It would then be considered satisfactory for general release. Mrs Godbole of
1.7 British attitude and
Indian attitude.
1.7.1 A BRITISH MURDERER
Nicholas Ingram a British born convicted murderer was finally sent to
the electrical chair in
Ann Campbell, Labour M.P from
WHEN WAS SUCH CONCERN SHOWN BY THE NEHRUS AND GANDHIS
FOR INDIANS?. Now you know why the British love them so much.
No one asked the question - But why did Ingram go to
1.7.2 HOSTAGES IN
On 7 July it was announced on radio that five mountaineers were
kidnapped in
" What is the Government of India doing about seeking release of these
hostages? " Instead of asking
" why on earth the mountaineers went to an area where two earlier
kidnappings had taken place ? why did they go there in the first place ?
We must learn to be suspicious about such events. It may well be that
these hostages are spies for western governments. They may be in league with their
kidnappers. They may have deliberately gone there and arranged to be kidnapped
to give publicity to so called grievances of
"A degree of autonomy for
Had Indians been caught in a similar situation it would not have made headlines
in the newspapers to start with. If it did the editors would have said "
we did not ask them to go there. Now they must suffer."
1.7.3 ENDING OF WORLD WAR II
The British, with the help of Americans and the Russians won the Second World
War 50 years ago. They celebrated that occasion on 19/20 August. Fine. But why
a VE (Victory in
The irony was that it was the Americans who defeated Japan not
1.7.4 YET ANOTHER BRITISH CRIMINAL
Nick Leeson, a trader made his employer Barings International Bank
bankrupt by his shady deals in
( Daily Telegraph 13 Sept 95, p 29 )
1.8 Visitors
Prof. Shreenivas Tilak teaches Indology at
stopped in
conference there. In
Dr Vijay Bedekar attended an international conference on the science of
museums, in
home for a week in July.
1.9 Hindu Awakening at last?
Sangh Sandesh of July/August 1992 carried an appeal from Mr Varma. He says
-
SIGNALS FROM THE PAST - AN APPEAL FOR MATERIAL FOR
PARTITION - TIME HISTORY
The freedom struggle in
There was treachery, injustice and torture on one side and bravery,
sacrifice and dedication to ancestral heritage on the other. That the saga of
those incidents may not be lost to posterity, a project for collection of all
material (incidents and facts) connected with partition has been taken up under
Shree Baba Saheb Apte Smarak Samiti.........
At the end Mr Varma rightly says," These signals from the past will
become directives for the future and to ensure that such incidents are never
repeated again."
Mr Varma's address is :-
D
Secretary, Bharat Vibhajan Samagri Sankalan
Keshav Kunj
Jhandewala
1.10 We are treated badly by
others, but do we deserve better ?
1.10.1 Mr Laxman Govind Toye was an Architect. He published his
autobiography in Marathi in March 1993 entitled mee ek vastukalakar
On page 144 he tells us about Gandhi memorial in
mind? How does he portray Gandhi's treachery and betrayal of Hindus? his
constant capitulation to Muslim demands, his callous attitude to Hindu
(including Sikhs ) refugees who sought shelter wherever they could find including
houses of Muslims who had gone to
And as if this was not enough he shamelessly says that he even submitted
a proposal for Jinnah's tomb in
1.10.2 We came across a letter published in The New York Times of
Bangladeshis. Hindus have been hounded out of that country ever since
1947
even when it was
Why should others treat us Indians any better ?
2 Historical findings
2.1 MUSLIM
British newspapers carried an interesting news item on
The Sun reported " Council's Gaffe on Graves of Muslims "
Two hundred Muslims have been buried facing the wrong way at a council
cemetery in a blunder costing thousands of pounds. An Islamic priest was
horrified when he visited the graveyard and discovered the bodies did not look
east towards
(Nottingham City Council) said :' We were given wrong advice.
We don't know who was responsible'
Sufi Ramzan, Spokesman for Nottingham Islamic Centre said :' What has happened
was a sin but it was forgiven because it was not deliberate. We did not ask for bodies to be exhumed and
reburied. We don't wish to disturb human remains.'
And yet historians want us to believe that the body of Mumtaz was
exhumed after six months burial at Burhanpur, taken to
2.2 WARTIME
The Daily Telegraph carried an
article by Mr W F Deedes on
wrote :- The rose coloured myths of wartime.
As VE-Day approaches, a wistful thought will pass through many minds,
particularly elderly ones. If only this country could somehow summon the
will, the character, the virtues, which we displayed throughout the Second
World War, how splendid it would be. During those years, so the thinking goes,
we were a united nation, of one mind and purpose. Many of our young men became
warriors. And even those who did not join the colours gave their best to the
war
effort.
This portrait of ourselves at war, shortly to be reinforced by countless
black and white photographs of smiling air raid wardens, gallant girls in the Women's
Land Army,
Sadly, we were not all that virtuous. Criminals, it seems, could spare
enough time from their war effort to raise the crime rate by half as much again
between 1939 and 1945. Breaking and entering offences soared from 11,714 in
1939 to 21,260 in 1945 - mainly, it is disclosed as a result of looting of bombed
properties. Yes the bodies of those killed in the Blitz were also looted.
The divorce rate soared. Those of us who censored soldiers' letters home
know the reason why. A great many wives found separation from husbands locked
into the Services impossible to bear. They sought and found consolation
elsewhere. It became very hard on soldiers who received an inkling of this in
the course of battle, when the mail from home came in. Those of us reading
their anguished letters had insight into that.
In our corner of the battle for
I have described elsewhere how just after D-Day London dockers refused
to load our motor battalion's unfamiliar half-track vehicles - also provided by
There were plenty of strikes, and strong male resistance to the growing
labour force of women. Farmers served the nation splendidly, but even they had their
funny little ways. War profiteers were not confined to our industrial cities.
By no means everybody
accepted the increasingly stringent rations prescribed by the Ministry of Food.
Those who could afford it paid for more than their share.
There was much urgent war work which was commissioned and paid for on the
basis of " cost plus " - which meant that the manufacturer charged
what he thought fit - with a margin for profit added and unchallenged. ....War
offered more
temptations than peace to what we later came to know as the "spiv
" Shortages breed rackets. I suspect there was less violent crime than there
is today, but short of that, crime and dishonesty flourished, not least because
policemen had too much else to do.
So how have we come through the last 50 years in the undiminished glow
of those sunny posters which the Ministry of Information circulated as war-time
propaganda? Most people under 60 have been brought up on this myth of a selfless,
crimeless nation, dedicated to the defeat of Nazi Germany, alongside which John
Major's
Of course, the war produced fine human qualities which are not much cultivated
in peace. Some of its phases, the Battle of Britain,
Then we extolled our virtues. Now we parade our vices. Human nature does
not alter much. We should take note of what Fighting with Figures belatedly reminds
us of - and cheer up.
[ Fighting with Figures published by HMSO price £19.95 ]
3. How history gets twisted/
falsified even today
3.1 HOW THE BRITISH TREATED SAVARKAR.
Government of
(A) Internment in
Ratnagiri [1924-37]
In 1924 Savarkar was released from prison on two conditions that -
(1) he will stay in Ratnagiri
(2) he will not take part in politics.
Both conditions were applicable for 5 years only. But the British
administration kept on increasing the limit every two years. Eventually when
Provincial Autonomy was granted, it was Jamnadas Mehta who secured
unconditional release of Savarkar in 1937. The wickedness of the British does
not come out in the film.
(B) The film also
shows Savarkar writing on prison walls in
(Kalapani), as if by permission of the prison authorities. What is the
truth?
As a prisoner Savarkar was not allowed to keep any paper or pencil. To
do so
was a punishable offence. One day he had an brilliant idea. Why not use
the
prison wall ? So he started to write with a thorn of a tree - even that
was an offence - and his elder brother was indeed punished for such an offence!
From time to time Savarkar was transferred from cell to cell. All the
writings on the wall had to be memorised.
(C) Normally any
prisoner would be allowed to settle outside the prison ( but
on
3.2 PRISON CONDITIONS OF SAVARKAR / TILAK / NEHRU
In his biography of Lokamanya Tilak, Dhananjay Keer writes," Modern Indian
literature, especially its bright part, is much indebted to British
tyranny over
( Lokamanya Tilak, 1969, p 329 )
This creates a false picture of writings under similar conditions. Let
us look at the facts.
1. Tilak, aged 52 was transported to
He wrote his Gita Rahasya during November 1910 and March 1911
( Lokamanya Tilak by Keer 1969, pp 320-329 )
Tilak himself wrote,"... For some time, only four books were
allowed to be kept with me at a time. ....I protested and said I needed other
books for reference....... My application was granted. ......They would not
give me loose papers for writing. Only bound books with numbered pages were
given. No ink and pen, but only pencils were given. No penknife was allowed and
the pencils were mended for me by the jailer's peon. Ink and pen were only supplied
when the monthly letter to
( Bal Gangadhar Tilak by T V
Parvate, 1972, pp 304/5 )
Savarkar's jail conditions were even worse than Tilak's. He was
transported for life twice, to
Such were the conditions under which Savarkar's poetry was born.
Jawaharal Nehru benefited from the sacrifices and struggles put up by
earlier political prisoners. In 1930-31 he was arrested. But he enjoyed the
status of 'A' class prisoners. He faced none of the hardships or deprivations
faced by either Savarkar or Tilak. And what did he write? His own biography!
That does not require any research or study. It was published in 1936 by
It is surprising that a scholar like Mr Keer should make such a grossly
unfair
comparison.
3.3 INDIAN WAR OF
We explained in our Newsletter 22 of
Why blame others that they twist and falsify Indian history ?
Government of
Even Sir Sayyad Ahmad Khan, the Muslim separatist wrote a book in 1858 entitled,"
causes of the Indian Revolt "
As we publish this newsletter, Balarao Savarkar has agreed to make
corrections in future editions of Savarkar's books.
4 Behaviour of Christians and
Muslims today
4.1 MUSLIM FANATICISM
on 5 May 1995 Michael Binyon Diplomatic Editor of the TIMES wrote,
" Algerian militants threaten to kill women."
Hundreds of thousands of wives, mothers and daughters of the troops,
police and government servants fighting the Muslim militants in
The Armed Islamic Group ( GIA), most violent of the Islamic
fundamentalists fighting the Algerian military Government, published its
warning in a communiqué to a London-based Arab newspaper. Previous warnings of terrorist
action have usually been followed by bomb explosions and assassinations.
The warning, issued to women on Wednesday, was published in al-Hayat, and
threatened to kill all women associated with the regime who failed to wear a
veil or insisted in acquiring an education instead of remaining closeted in
their homes.
The warning, signed by Abu Abdallah Ahmad, the group's leader, said that
every woman still married to an "atheist" risked death.
Fundamentalists define atheists as all those who advocate secularism or do not
subscribe to their draconian interpretation of Islam.
" Every renegade's wife must
leave him because the marriage is considered annulled without the involvement
of a judge, because of his (the husband's ) heresy." It added," Every
man who, after the publication of this statement, marries a woman under his
authority off to a renegade - whether it is his daughter, his sister or his
mother - leaves her exposed to death and himself to torture."
The GIA has consistently advocated ruthless violence and called for a
strict Islamic state in which women would play no political or social role.
Women have frequently been the targets for GIA killings and more than 20 have
been murdered because they refused to accept a " temporary marriage "
to Muslim fighters [ There is such a thing as a temporary marriage acceptable
to Islamic Fundamentalists.]
Al-Hayat, owned by Saudi
interests, is one of the most influential of the pan-
Arab newspapers.
4.2 ISLAMIC BROTHERHOOD OF MAN
On 7 July Ahmed Rashid reported from
says,"
The Muhajir Quami Movement, the party of Urdu-speaking migrants from India,
whose militants have plunged Karachi into the worst month of violence the port
city has ever endured, has said it will send a delegation to Islamabad on
Sunday to begin talks with the Bhutto government.
The talks, expected to start yesterday, were postponed after the
movement's leaders said they had to consult their chief, Altaf Hussain, who is
in exile in
The Bhutto government depends heavily on support from Sindhis, the majority
ethnic group in Sind province of which
The violence increased at the end of June when militants closed off many
areas to security patrols with road blocks and constant sniping. Using rocket launchers
and machine-guns they attacked trains, bombarded a television station and other
government buildings, set fire to more than 1,000 vehicles and hit an airforce
transport plane. More than 100 security personnel have been shot dead by the
militants. In several
So much for the Islamic
Brotherhood of man! The picture has not changed for last ten years. Mr
Godbole travelled to
4.3 MUSLIMS IN
Sandra Laville reported for the Evening
Standard on 11 May 1995 :
WARNING AS
Community leaders and a senior police officer warned today that national
tensions between militant groups of Sikh and Moslem youths would erupt
on the streets of
Two hundred police officers, some with riot shields and batons, were
called in yesterday to keep hundreds of Moslems and Sikhs apart during the
second biggest festival on the Moslem calendar, the Eid Yi Adha, in Southall Broadway.
Twenty-five youths were arrested when clashes broke out over an 11-hour period
during the celebrations.
4.4 RACIST MAIL BOYCOTT
The Independent reported on 15
August 1995 :-
5. Victorian
BBC2 carried a series called FORBIDDEN BRITAIN. More about it in the
next
newsletter.
6. Why we cannot tell the
truth
The Daily Telegraph reported on 8
September 1994 :-
CIA woman ' victimised for reporting on bosses '
A woman intelligence officer is claiming the CIA ruined her career
because she reported her top deputy for wife beating, and security breaches by
others. In an unusual sex discrimination suit, the woman claimed CIA officials retaliated
against her, beginning in 1991, by denying her promotion and smearing her by
falsely accusing her of misconduct.
The suit is remarkable because of the explicit nature of complaints.
Although pseudonyms are used in the complaint, it is clear the accessions are
aimed at senior officers. The woman identified as " Jane Doe Thompson
" joined the CIA in 1968 and still works in its clandestine service, which
recruits and handles spies abroad. The suit was filed in the district court in
We are all scared for our
jobs. So are Indian historians who refuse to
face truth about Taj Mahal.
7. Acknowledgement
We are grateful to the following for their help :-
• For posting copies of our newsletters in
Dr Bedekar of
• For making copies of our newsletters and distributing them to
friends:-
An anonymous friend from
of
• For distributing copies of Why
Rewrite Indian History? and Mr
Godbole's
book on Taj Mahal to friends in
Mr S Kale of
• For arranging slide shows on Taj Mahal :-
Mr Sudhir Patel of
• For arranging Around London Tour
Kishor Dhabi of Leeds ( our gratitude to Manohar Rakhe of
providing refreshments in the morning and lunch in the afternoon for 15
guests)
• For editing the video of Around
London Tour :-
Hemant Padhya of
• For donating £5 for our cause :-
Mrs Dipali Ghosh of
• For arranging a collection of $200 for the publication of Mr Godbole's
book
Taj Mahal and the Great British Conspiracy -
Viraj Sardesai of
8. Publicity and Appreciation
Dr N K Bhide of Pune wrote that he heard someone praising our Around
Sangh Sandesh of July / August
1995 carried an article by A S Kulkarni on
God bole's Around
Please help by :-
* acknowledging the receipt of this newsletter to the following address
Mr V S Godbole
14 Turnberry Walk
MK41,8AZ
* sending money to Mr Godbole (in pound sterling or Indian rupees )
* making 5 copies of this newsletter and sending them to your friends.
* circulating this newsletter among your friends.
* trying to get parts of this newsletter published in various
newspapers, magazines and periodicals
* arranging slide shows by Godbole at various social functions.